Form: Short academic thesis
Written: Fall 2013 – Summer 2014


For centuries, St. Augustine’s perspective on desire and sexuality were taken for granted: that lust was a cardinal sin, that babies born of any sexual act (marital or otherwise) were damned, carrying within them the sin of Adam until baptized. Beginning in the mid-20th century, however, theologians in and outside the Church began wondering if Augustine had been wrong on one or two of these accounts. Joining this conversation in the late 1970s, Pulitzer Prize winning author John Updike critiques and reimagines Augustine’s theology of desire in his short story “Augustine’s Concubine,” a retelling of Confessions. Updike offers a way into understanding Augustine’s theology of desire that avoids oversimplifying, as others have done. This paper analyzes Updike’s criticism of both the Augustinian tradition and its modern opposite, the Freudian tradition, and considers “Augustine’s Concubine” as an embodied critique of these traditions. It then looks at St. Augustine’s theology of desire, as explicated in his Confessions, to show how it deepens the meaning of Updike’s story. Finally, this paper explores the recent work of theologian Sarah Coakley in forming a theology of desire for the contemporary Church.

Related Posts

Essays

Gender, Marriage, and the שִׁירָה of God

Form: Essay Written: Spring 2013 In the creation myth of Genesis 1-3, God called everything into being. From emptiness, She created form. From dirt, She created life. God saw everything She created and called it Read more...

Essays

Shocking Sisters: Exegesis of Ezekiel 23

Form: Exegetical Essay Written: Summer 2013 “Wild Nights—Wild Nights! / Were I with thee / Wild Nights should be Our luxury!” –Emily Dickinson, “Wild Nights—Wild Nights!”[1] “Is he still coming around like an injured bird needing Read more...

Essays

No Savior at All: Updike’s Black Jesus and the White Church

Form: Essay Written: Winter 2016/’17 Published by: The Other Journal A sign of the times, outrage followed the February release of Beyoncé’s “Formation” music video and her performance at the Super Bowl 50 halftime show. Read more...